Certain Underwriters at Lloyd's and Soline Trading Ltd. v. Mediterranean Shipping Company S.A., 2017 FC 460, 2017 FC 893

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

Précis: The Federal Court held it had no jurisdiction to adjudicate a third party claim for indemnity brought by the ocean carrier against a trucker who took delivery of the cargo either unlawfully or negligently.

Full Summary

Atlantic Container Lines AB v. Cerescorp Company, 2017 FC 465

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

Précis: The Federal Court permitted a defendant to amend its Statement of Defence to allege additional causes of the collapse of a stow of containers where the amendments were not a radical departure from prior pleadings, were not doomed to fail and the motion to amend was made in a timely fashion.

Full Summary

Freightlift Private Limited v. Entrepot DMS Warehouse Inc.,, 2011 FC 280

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

The plaintiff in this action was an Indian freight forwarder who had been retained to arrange shipment of four containers of clothing to Montreal. The bills of lading for the containers named the plaintiff as consignee because the purchaser had not paid for the cargo. The purchaser was in fact unable to pay for the cargo when it arrived and, …

Full Summary

Bank of the West v. The 26' Well Craft Scarab (Ship), 2007 FC 1112 (CanLII)

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

The Defendant marine insurer sought leave to amend its pleading to plead a limitation period contained in its policy. At first instance the Prothonotary denied the application without giving reasons. On appeal, the motions Judge noted the general rule is to allow amendments at any stage of an action provided there is no prejudice or injustice to the other party …

Full Summary

Addo v. OT Africa Line et al., 2006 FC 1099 (CanLII)

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

The Plaintiff was the owner of goods that were damaged when the container in which the goods were stowed was dropped at the Port of Antwerp. The Plaintiff commenced proceedings against various parties including the operator of the port where the container was dropped. That Defendant brought this motion to strike the Plaintiff’s claim on the basis that it disclosed …

Full Summary

Canada Steamship Lines Inc. v. Elliott, 2006 FC 609

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

This was a motion to strike a counterclaim on the grounds that it failed to disclose a reasonable cause of action. The counterclaim alleged an intentional interference with contractual relations relating to the use of a ship. The motion was denied by the Prothonotary who reviewed the relevant authorities and concluded that the impugned pleading contained allegations of the essential …

Full Summary

Kona Concept Inc. v. Guimond Boats Limited, 2005 FC 214

In Admiralty Practice, Pleadings on (Updated )

In this matter the Plaintiff commenced proceedings against the Defendant in Hawaii in relation to a contract for the design, manufacture and sale of a tuna fishing boat. The Defendant initially contested the jurisdiction of the Hawaiian courts but after having lost its jurisdiction motion withdrew from that action. The Plaintiff subsequently obtained a default judgment against the Defendant and …

Full Summary