The defendant ship was ordered to be sold and the order of sale provided that all reasonable expenses and agency fees necessary for the preservation, safekeeping or maintenance of the vessel were to be treated as sheriff’s costs. Upon assessment of the sheriff’s costs certain invoices and expenses were contested by one of the parties. The contested invoices included: amounts …
Full SummaryT. Co. Metals LLC v. The Federal Ems, 2011 FC 291, 2012 FCA 284
A cargo of cold-rolled steel coils was carried from Brazil to Toronto pursuant to bills of lading that incorporated the terms and conditions of a voyage charterparty between the exporter and the time charterer of the vessel. Pursuant to the terms of the voyage charterparty, the exporter was to be responsible for the loading, stowing and discharging of the cargo. …
Full SummaryCalogeras & Master Supplies Inc v. Ceres Hellenic Shipping Enterprises Ltd., 2011 FC 1276, 2012 FCA 244
The plaintiff, ship chandler, had been successful at trial and was awarded damages of approximately $100,000 for unpaid invoices. The plaintiff now sought to recover its legal fees, which were recoverable pursuant to the terms of the contract. The defendant also sought costs on the basis that the plaintiff’s award did not exceed a settlement offer the defendants had made. …
Full SummarySeanautic Marine Inc. v. Jofor Export Incorporated, 2012 FC 328
Précis: The court affirmed that dismissal of a prior proceeding without an adjudication on the merits is not a bar to later proceedings.
Full SummaryCameco Corporation v. The "MCP Altona", 2012 FC 324
Précis: The court declined to return security given by cargo interests even though the shipowner was bankrupt, unbeknownst to the parties, at the time security was given.
Full SummaryCalogeras & Master Supplies Inc. v. Ceres Hellenic Shipping Enterprises Ltd., 2012 FCA 79
The plaintiff had obtained a judgment against the defendant for $100,000 plus interest and a costs award of approximately $35,000. The defendant had also been awarded costs in the amount of approximately $160,000 from the date of an offer it had made and had been given the right to set-off its costs award against amounts owing to the plaintiff. The …
Full SummarySecunda Marine Services Ltd. v. Caterpillar Inc, 2012 NSSC 53
Précis: The plaintiff was allowed to amend its claim by adding a new plaintiff 10 years after the incident giving rise to the claim.
Full SummaryTAM International Inc. v. The " MCP Altona", 2012 FC 128
Précis: Costs were awarded against a party that withdrew a claim against proceeds of sale.
Full SummaryFFS HK Ltd v. P.T. 25 (Ship), 2011 BCSC 1418
In this matter the plaintiff was successful at trial in that it obtained an order that the defendant was 50% at fault for a pollution incident. The plaintiff now sought to recover its costs. The plaintiff was awarded special costs and 100% of its costs and disbursements. Special costs were awarded primarily because the defendant advanced evidence of a witness …
Full SummaryCF Boatworks Inc. v. James, 2011 FC 1101
In this matter the defendant’s statement of defence had been struck for failure to provide a list of documents or written answers to interrogatories. The plaintiff now brought this motion for default judgment. The Prothonotary noted that on a motion for default judgement there are two questions: is the defendant in default and is there evidence to support the plaintiff’s …
Full Summary