Mil Davie Inc. v. Hibernia Management and Development Co. Ltd.

In Admiralty Practice, Other Practice Topics on (Updated )

This was an application by the Defendant for summary judgment dismissing the Plaintiff’s action. In the underlying action the Plaintiff, a ship repair yard, alleged that the Defendant awarded contracts to a competitor without seeking tenders and in violation of the Competition Act and the Offshore Accord Acts. The motions Judge reviewed the jurisprudence on summary judgments and noted in particular that summary judgment applications are not appropriate where credibility is in issue. The motions Judge found that there were genuine issues for trial and that issues of credibility had been raised and he therefore declined to grant summary judgment.